Thursday, June 20, 2013

How a Portrait Should Look




Glyn Warren Philpot, R.A. (1884-1937), Portrait of
 Ellen Borden Stevenson, oil on canvas, 32 x 24 in., Christie's, London

Without a doubt, this is how a commissioned oil portrait should look when painted from life.  What else can one conclude?  Just look at it.  The creamy, flawless flesh of youth is painted to perfection.  The expression is flattering, lively and lifelike, not emotionally dead as in all of today’s photographically rendered portraits that the public pays darn good money for.  The drawing is excellent and the details subordinate to the sitter’s lovely countenance.  The pale color theme is unobtrusive, soothing and exquisite.  Have you ever seen a portrait painted in the last 30 years that looked as good?  I didn’t think so. 

This portrait radiates all the bloom of life emanating from this beautiful young woman, and it is a look that no photograph could ever capture.  Where and why have we gone wrong!  Who wouldn’t want to try to paint such a lovely portrait for themselves today?  Is it simply that we lack the ability to paint this well?  Are we just not interested in capturing the emotional state of the sitter in front of us? Has the photograph rendered us incapable of appreciating natural beauty, the softness of real flesh, the curious, lively gaze of the sitter as the painter goes about his work, the mouth at its most seductive transition, the sparkle in the eye, the arched eyebrow that adds such playfulness and joy to the portrait.  What a nice painting! 

Glyn Warren Philpot, Self-Portrait

Glyn Warren Philpot, R.A. (1884-1937) was a highly accomplished, successful portrait painter in England in the 1920s and 30s who had studied painting at the Lambeth School of Art in London and at the Academie Julian in Paris under J.P. Laurens.  After travels to Spain, his portrait work reflected his love for the paintings of Velázquez.  In notes for the auction of this portrait in London on July 11, a Christie’s specialist writes, “Faced with the young American girl, Ellen Borden, clad in pale lemon trimmed with gauze, it was not surprising to find Philpot producing a modern 'infanta'.”   Philpot’s contemporaries considered him to be a masterful craftsman.  And critics celebrated his exceptional ability to capture the sitter’s personality, particularly in his informal portraiture.  This more formal portrait of Ellen Borden surely must have confirmed that attribute of his work.  Philpot also painted genre studies and religious, mythological and allegorical subjects, and was a sculptor, as well.   Apparently some of his later work was too sexually explicit for the public and he suffered financially as a result.

In Harold Speed’s outstanding 1924 treatise on the “science and practice” of oil painting, now titled “Oil Painting Techniques and Materials,” he lists some palettes of contemporary English painters, and here is the list of colors obtained from Philpot, right to left, with colors used occasionally in Italics: Light red, Indian red, Vermillion, White, Yellow ochre, Raw umber, Burnt umber, Ivory black, Cerulean blue, Cobalt, Terra vert, Burnt sienna.  He used copal varnish thinned with turpentine for his medium and for glazes.  And just to show how serious I am about this technical stuff, I even looked up the definition of “ultramarine ash,” which Philpot sometimes used for delicate grays.  Here is the 1913 definition, brought to you courtesy of the Internet: “Ultramarine ash is a pigment which is the residuum of lapis lazuli after the ultramarine has been extracted.  It was used by the old masters as a middle or neutral tint for flesh, skies, and draperies, being of a purer and tenderer gray than that produced by the mixture of more positive colors.”  But you probably already knew this.  Sounds something like Gamblin’s Torrit Grey, made of recycled pigment dust, although I’m sure nobody uses that color for anything other than to enter a painting in the manufacturer’s annual Torrit Grey competition!

Philpot’s list of colors won’t help us paint better, of course.  But can’t we try to connect emotionally with each subject, as he must have done, and not strive so hard to get a frozen, photographic likeness in our portrait work?  Shouldn’t we strive to let our sitters be recognized on canvas as the distinct, living and breathing individuals they are, rather than as exact replicas of a photograph?   But maybe we’re not so interested anymore in rendering soft, tender flesh in all its natural beauty.  We’re being taught to prefer the glossy, plastic flesh of dinosaurs, aliens, action heroes and supermodels nowadays. 

Figurative painters working from life in a traditional manner know that the sitter and the painter are in this together, and painting skill only takes you halfway up the mountain to a heavenly portrait like this one of Ellen Borden (1908-1972).  The daughter of a prominent Chicago family made wealthy through real estate investments and mining operations, she was educated at finishing schools and studied independently in England and Italy.  She was an excellent pianist and trained as a mezzo-soprano.  Her portrait was painted before she married a young lawyer named Adlai Stevenson in 1928, when she had not yet turned 20.  She divorced him in 1949.  Their marriage became strained as Stevenson rose within the ranks of the Democratic Party, culminating in his two unsuccessful bids for the Presidency, in 1952 and 1956.  Ellen apparently voted Republican.